Peer Review Process

PEER REVIEW PROCESS

Authors must submit manuscripts through the system to be considered for publication in a journal published by the Indonesian Journals Center Lingkar Pena Indonesia (YLPMI). Please send manuscripts for online submission.

To be published, after passing the submission process, manuscripts must undergo a double-blind peer review process to ensure academic quality and integrity. We only publish articles that qualified researchers with expertise in the relevant field have reviewed and approved.

The editorial board will decide whether to accept or reject the manuscripts submitted by authors based on the review results. The first screening is conducted by the editors, assessing the content/scope and novelty of the submitted article. After the first screening, to ensure a fair review process, our journal typically involves each article in a review by at least two reviewers.

There is no communication between authors and reviewers during the review process. Furthermore, there is no communication between authors and editors regarding rejection decisions.

Authors whose papers are accepted, revised, or rejected will be informed of the outcome by the reviewers.

REVIEW PROCESS

The review process consists of the following stages:

     1. Manuscript Submission: Author submits manuscript through OJS system

     2. Initial Screening: Editors check for scope appropriateness, novelty, and plagiarism screening (using Turnitin)

     3. Peer Review: Manuscript sent to at least 2 qualified reviewers with expertise in relevant fields

     4. Decision Notification: Editor notifies author of acceptance, revision, or rejection based on reviewers' comments

     5. Revision: Author revises manuscript based on reviewers' suggestions

     6. Final Decision: Editor makes final publication decision after reviewing revisions

The journal typically requires at least two rounds of review. Possible decisions include:

  • Accept without changes
  • Accept with minor revisions
  • Accept after major revisions
  • Revise and resubmit
  • Reject